If you know Z, you know he likes to talk. Okay, it some instances he likes to talk. When it he gets going, whoa! He's a much better talker than he is a writer, and one aspect of schooling I've wanted to add is oral exams. How do you grade an oral exam? And what makes it an exam and not simply a conversation?
In Philosophy this year we are reading
The Theory of Knowledge. Awesome book. He is doing a project with some of the chapters and this week's was language. So fitting, so perfect. Z and I have also being toying with our own alphabet and language. This has been going on for a few years and we've let it lie for a while. So Z decides he wants to write an alphabet, not a language, for his project. He had started part of one, but wasn't finished. He turned the completed alphabet yesterday. That was the written portion of his assignment.
For the oral part we had a question and answer session about his alphabet. I'm his mom, he's my only child, we have sort of a code language already. He finishes my sentences, I can read his thoughts, stuff like that. To eliminate that familiarity I reminded him to consider me as someone who knew nothing about his project. I had googled for a oral exam rubric and found one that met my needs - rubrics can be great, yet you have to find the right one for your needs. Some are too vague, some not enough categories. The one I found was college level, so there was more definition between levels than simply poor, average, good, or excellent.
In addition to the previous question and answer session, I asked some questions taken from a Theory of Knowledge study guide on the IB website. Theory of Knowledge is an IB course, which obviously we can't do IB at the homeschool level, but I find the course companion (linked above) to be a great introduction to the ways and whys of thinking. As he answered the questions, I wrote notes and used my rubric to grade his remarks.
Z has a passion for language, even the absurdity of English. This was an easy topic for him to discuss. However, I found the manner in which he answered and his overall communication skills to be great. It's almost as if I had stepped outside of my own familiarity with him and saw how he would respond if I hadn't been the one examining him.
After his exam I created a template for my grading notes. Grades are not a huge motivator for Z, yet I want detailed records to support my grading, especially in subjects that have a less defined way of evalution.
My template included these categories:
Subject: Philosophy
Date: 28 September 2012
Material Covered: Theory of Knowledge, chapter 3 Language
Material Graded: Oral examination and written work
Grading system: this is where I noted where I got my questions and what I used to grade the written work
Grading Scale: The rubric I used had 120 points possible (more nuanced than a 1-4 scale). I chose 30 points for the written work, 20 for the work itself, 5 for being on time, 5 for neatness (meeting deadlines and being neat are two skills we are building this year)
Summation of Oral Exam: this is where I typed up my evaluation of his remarks. I pulled a few phrases from the rubric to document I actually used it as part of the criteria.
Summation of Written Work: This is where I wrote my evaluation of his written work, noting the time he spent on it in and outside of class, I also noted which skills he used to finish this assignment, as in creativity and critical thinking skills.
In the end, I have detailed documentation of his grade and how he earned it. Next week we're studying perception. I can't wait to see what kind of project he comes up for that one.